Skip to main content
planin30

Investment Mix for Two — One of you wants more stocks. The other wants less.

Each of you picks the share of stocks that feels right, seeing what it would have lost in a real bad year. Get a shared mix you can both stay with, safety money for the next five years, and how long the money lasts.

  • Free to start
  • No sign-up to try
  • For two, or just you
A couple in their late fifties laughing together on the sofa with mugs of tea
Dan 80% stocks, Maria 40%Together: 55% stocks · −$144,000 in a year like 2008

Everything in one answer

Each of your choices with what it would lose, the shared mix and where each dollar goes, the three run through the same markets, and the return your plan actually needs.

Each of your choices

Answer separately: how much in stocks feels right?

Every choice shows what it would have lost in the worse of two real bad years: 2008, when stocks fell 37%, and 2022, when stocks and bonds fell together. Then the savings, any big costs in the next five years, and what you will take out each year.

“80% stocks: −29% in 2008” · “40% stocks: −15% in 2022”The two choices in the “Ten years from retiring” example
  • One question each, with a real bad year beside every answer
  • Savings, big costs coming and yearly withdrawals, in today’s dollars
  • How the mix is chosen and inflation, in one fold
Each partner’s choice, then the savings and what comes out of them: Your choices

Your choices 1/2

A couple in their fifties at a kitchen table, each writing on their own notepad and smiling at each other

The shared mix

A mix that leans toward the more cautious of you.

A partner who sells in a crash costs more than a slightly lower return, so the shared mix sits a third of the way from the cautious choice to the bolder one. Money you will spend in the next five years is held as safety money that doesn’t fall. If you are far apart, the bolder one can run a small account of their own, taken out of the shared stocks so it adds no risk.

“A mix you can both live with: 55% stocks.” · In a year like 2008: −$144,000, a fall of about 18%.The same example
  • The shared stock share, and what it would lose in dollars
  • Safety money for five years of withdrawals and big costs
  • An optional account for the bolder partner, without added risk
The shared mix, what it would lose in a bad year, what it is expected to earn and where the money goes
A retired couple tending vegetable beds in their backyard garden

Side by side

Your two choices and the shared mix, on the same markets.

All three run through the same 1,000 markets with everything you take out: what each would lose in a bad year, how often the money lasts, and what is left at the end in today’s dollars. Then the return your plan actually needs, because a plan that needs little can afford to take less risk.

Dan’s choice lasts in 70 of 100 markets, Maria’s in 77, together in 76 · The plan needs about 0.8% a year after inflation.Taking $32,000 a year from ten years on
  • Bad-year loss, how often it lasts, and what is left, for each
  • The return your plan needs, against what the mix earns
  • Withdrawals as a share of savings, beside the 4% rule
Each choice and the shared mix side by side, and the return the plan needs
A couple in their sixties talking it over with a financial planner

Year by year

The range of outcomes, not just the average.

The chart shows what the savings are worth each year with the shared mix: the middle market, and a band holding 8 markets in 10. Each of your own choices is a dashed line beside it. Switch between today’s dollars and future dollars. Under it, what to weigh beyond the numbers: where the safety money is kept, and which account holds what for tax.

“Keep the safety money where it can’t fall: a savings account, CDs or Treasury bills. Refill it from the invested money after a good year, not after a bad one.”Beyond the numbers
  • A band of outcomes, from 1 in 10 worse to 1 in 10 better
  • Each partner’s own choice, dashed, on the same chart
  • Today’s dollars or future dollars, one tap
The range of outcomes year by year, with each partner’s own choice dashed
A couple in their sixties hiking a forest trail together in autumn

Agree on a mix before the next bad year, not during it.

Free to start. No sign-up to try.

Find your own mix →

About the investment mix calculator

Couples often feel differently about risk. One of you can watch the savings fall by a fifth and hold on; the other would lose sleep at half that. A mix only works if both of you can stay with it through a bad year, because selling after a crash is what turns a fall on paper into a real loss.

Each of you picks the stock share that feels right, with what that choice would have lost in a real bad year beside it: 2008, when stocks fell 37%, or 2022, when stocks and bonds fell together. The calculator sets aside safety money for the next five years of withdrawals and any big costs, then suggests a shared mix for the rest that leans toward the more cautious of you. If your choices are far apart, the bolder one can run a small account of their own, taken out of the shared stocks so it adds no risk.

It runs the shared mix and each of your own choices through the same 1,000 markets, with everything you plan to take out, and shows what each would lose in a bad year, how often the money lasts, and what is left at the end in today’s dollars. It also shows the return your plan actually needs, because a plan that needs little can afford to take less risk.

What you can do

  • Each partner picks a stock share, shown with what it would have lost in 2008 or 2022
  • A shared mix between the two, leaning cautious or meeting in the middle
  • Safety money for five years of withdrawals and big costs, so a bad year never forces a sale
  • An optional account the bolder partner runs, without adding risk
  • Bad-year loss in dollars, how often the money lasts, and what is left, for each choice
  • The return your plan needs, against what the mix is expected to earn
  • Year-by-year range of outcomes, in today’s or future dollars

Frequently asked questions

What if my spouse and I disagree about how much risk to take?

Most planners lean the shared mix toward the more cautious partner, because the cost of one of you selling in a crash is larger than the cost of a slightly lower return. Setting aside five years of spending as safety money makes a bad year easier to sit through, and a small account the bolder partner runs gives them room without moving the whole plan.

Why keep five years of withdrawals in cash?

Stocks have usually recovered from a bad year within about five years. Money you will spend before then is held where it cannot fall, so you never have to sell stocks low to pay the bills. The calculator tops it up from the invested money only after a year that money grew, and holds the same safety money in every mix it compares, so the comparison is only about the invested money.

Why does it show 2022 as well as 2008?

In 2008 stocks fell 37% while high-quality bonds rose, so bonds cushioned the fall. In 2022 stocks fell 18% and bonds 13% at the same time, so a cautious mix heavy in bonds did worse that year than in 2008. Each mix is shown with the worse of the two.

Related calculators and planners

Other calculators and planners that pair well with the Investment Mix for Two: Asset Allocation Calculator.