Is Leasing a Car Cheaper Than Buying? Run the 3-Year Math
Leasing a car can have a lower monthly payment, but the three-year cost depends on resale value, fees, mileage, and equity. Run the math with a real scenario.
A lower payment isn’t always the cheaper car. Put the loan and the lease side by side, with the cash each leaves you to invest, and see what you’d have after the years you’ll drive it.

The loan costs more each month and leaves you a car; the lease costs less and leaves you the difference. This counts both, so the answer is what you end up with, not the payment.
Two ways to pay
Both paths start with the same cash at signing. Whichever costs less each month invests the difference. At the end, the buyer has a car worth something and the leaser has their investments: both are counted.
“Buying leaves you $6,496 more than leasing after 5 years, in today’s dollars.” · $7,323 in the dollars of 2031The answer on the “Toyota Highlander Hybrid, 5-yr buy (Maya & Devon)” example


Who ends ahead 2/2

How long you keep it
The end state shows what each path leaves you with. Then net wealth at every horizon from one to fifteen years: where the two lines cross is the point the choice changes.
Buy: equity $23,748 at year 5 · Lease: car returned, $0End state on the Highlander example


Keep it longer 2/2
The dealer’s quote
Residual, money factor, cap reduction and mileage cap, straight off the offer sheet. It shows the interest rate the money factor stands for and works out the payment, so you can check the number you were given.
Money factor 0.0027 = 6.48% APR · $547 a month before taxLease terms on the Highlander example


The lower monthly payment is not always the cheaper car decision. Leasing usually compresses the payment because you are paying for use, mileage, and depreciation during the lease term. Buying can cost more upfront, but it may leave you with equity and more flexibility if you keep the car longer.
Enter the lease offer, loan terms, down payment, mileage, fees, and expected resale value. The calculator compares total cost over the horizon you care about so the decision is based on the whole deal, not just the payment.
Leasing can look better when you want a new car every few years, drive predictable mileage, and value a lower monthly payment more than building equity. Buying often improves when you keep the car past the loan term or drive more than a lease allows.
Compare cash due at signing, fees, taxes, financing charges, mileage limits, maintenance, insurance, resale value, and whether you own anything at the end. A lower monthly payment can still lose over the full ownership period.
Money factor is the lease financing charge, similar to an interest rate. Residual value is the car's expected value at lease end. Together with the negotiated price, they drive how much depreciation and financing you pay for.
Most leases cap annual mileage and charge for extra miles or excess wear at the end. If you drive unpredictably, carry kids or gear, or expect to end the lease early, those charges can erase the apparent monthly-payment savings.
You usually return the car, buy it for the residual value, or start a new lease. The cheapest option depends on the car's market value, mileage, condition, purchase-option fees, and whether you still want the same vehicle.
Practical examples that connect the calculator to real planning decisions.
Leasing a car can have a lower monthly payment, but the three-year cost depends on resale value, fees, mileage, and equity. Run the math with a real scenario.
Compare leasing vs buying a car with a real 2026 scenario. Learn how monthly payments, mileage limits, equity, fees, and time horizon change the real cost.
Other calculators, planners and tools that pair well with the Car Buy vs Lease Calculator.
Photos by Annie Spratt and Martina Carinci on Unsplash.