Why Buying Is Not Always Cheaper Than Renting
Buying is not always cheaper than renting. See a concrete 2026 rent-vs-buy scenario where renting and investing the difference can stay ahead for decades.
The same cash down two paths: buy and carry a mortgage, or rent and invest the difference. See which leaves you with more after the years you’ll stay, and what would change it.

Rent is money gone and a mortgage builds equity: true, and only half the story. This compares the whole of both, including what the renter’s cash earns.
Two paths
Buy, and the cash becomes a down payment and closing costs. Rent, and it goes into investments, along with whatever renting saves each month. After the years you’ll stay, both are counted the same way: what you’d have.
“Renting ends $80,000 ahead” after 5 years, in today’s dollars ($92,000 in the dollars of 2031)The answer on the “Rent or buy in Austin? (Maya & Devon)” example


Who ends ahead 2/2

Break-even
One tap works out the home-price growth, the rent or the investment return at which the two paths end even, so you can judge how likely buying is to come out ahead.
Home appreciation 6.16% · “the home growth where buying and renting end up even”Break-even rate on the “Rent or buy in Austin?” example


Costs, year by year
Interest, principal, property tax, insurance and maintenance for the owner; rent for the renter. Then the totals each one has paid out, and what each is worth at the end.
Owner total outlay $239,000 · Renter total outlay $142,000, at year 5 in today’s dollarsKey numbers on the “Rent or buy in Austin?” example


Costs, year by year 1/2

Your loan and refinancing
The buyer’s loan year by year: interest, principal and what is still owed the year you sell. Then try a lower rate in a later year, and see whether the savings pay back the closing costs before you move. Or pay points at closing, or take a lender credit, and see the same test.
“The savings take 4 years to pay back the $13,576 of costs, longer than you plan to stay (you sell in year 5).”Refinancing at 5.95% in year 3, on the “Rent or buy in Austin?” example



Your loan, year by year 1/3

The "rent is throwing money away" trope misses the opportunity cost of the down payment. If you buy, the down payment is locked up in a non-liquid asset earning the appreciation rate. If you rent, the same capital can sit in a 60/40 portfolio earning a different rate. The calculator runs both paths and tells you when buying overtakes renting in total wealth.
Realistically the answer depends on your hold period, your local rent vs price ratio, your interest rate, and the alternative investment return. We model all of them with sane defaults you can override.
It is the year when buying is projected to leave you ahead of renting, after ownership costs and the alternative of investing your cash. It is not a promise; it is a sensitivity point that changes when rates, rent, price growth, or time in the home change.
Years in the home, mortgage rate, rent growth, home appreciation, maintenance, property taxes, closing costs, selling costs, down payment, and investment return usually matter most. Small changes to those assumptions can move the break-even year.
Renting often leaves more cash outside the house. The calculator compares buying to renting and investing the down payment or monthly savings, so the result is about total wealth, not just the mortgage payment.
Not automatically. Ownership also brings closing costs, taxes, insurance, maintenance, HOA dues, selling costs, and less flexibility. If you may move soon, those costs can outweigh similar monthly payments.
There is no universal year count. Buying usually needs more time when closing costs, selling costs, maintenance, and mortgage interest are high. Renting can stay competitive when you invest the cash you would have put into the down payment.
Practical examples that connect the calculator to real planning decisions.
Buying is not always cheaper than renting. See a concrete 2026 rent-vs-buy scenario where renting and investing the difference can stay ahead for decades.
Learn the price-to-rent ratio formula, see a 2026 example, and test whether buying or renting looks stronger in the Rent vs. Buy Calculator.
Find your rent-vs-buy break-even year with a worked 2026 scenario and the three levers that most change the result.
Other calculators and planners that pair well with the Rent vs Buy Calculator.
Photo by Vitaly Gariev on Unsplash.