529 Plan vs Taxable Brokerage for College Savings
Compare a 529 plan vs a taxable brokerage for college savings with a concrete 12-year scenario, tax drag, flexibility tradeoffs, and 529 overfunding risks.
Each child, their school and their start date. What today’s savings cover, what they don’t, and the monthly amount that gets each one there.

Two kids four years apart, two kinds of school and one monthly budget. The calculator keeps each child’s numbers apart and adds them up for you.
A card per kid
In-state, out-of-state, private or a figure of your own. When they start, how many years, what’s saved and what goes in each month, and how much of it the family means to cover.
Maya · Private · $65,000/yr · $42,000 saved · $500/moMaya’s card on the “529 plans for Maya + Ethan (Boston)” example


Your kids 1/2

The gap
Each account’s balance year by year, through every year of college, and the point it runs short. The cost at enrollment is in the dollars of that year, so a ten-year-old’s private college reads as what it will cost then.
67% funded · $135,000 short, in today’s dollarsThe funding projection on the “529 plans for Maya + Ethan (Boston)” example


Balance over time 1/2

Solve the monthly
The answer says what fully funding it takes a month from now, and the one-time amount that would close the gap instead. One tap works out what each child needs a month for their balance to last to the end of college. Change a school or a date and work it out again.
Maya $1,278/mo · Ethan $528/moCalc on the “529 plans for Maya + Ethan (Boston)” example


Fully funded 2/2

Borrowing instead
For each child still short, the gap goes to federal student loans first, in the student’s name, then Parent PLUS loans in yours, at this year’s rates and fees. See the monthly payment after college, what is still left to find, and how much more saving now would cover the gap instead.
“With interest and fees you would pay back about $2.41 for every $1 that goes to college. Saving about $778 a month more from now would cover the whole gap instead.”Maya, on the “529 plans for Maya + Ethan (Boston)” example


Tax breaks
Pick your state and filing status to see this year’s and every year’s state tax saving, up to your state’s cap. Money left over can roll into the child’s Roth IRA under Secure 2.0, up to $35,000 each.
$1,419 saved on state income tax, until the kids turn 18The Massachusetts tax benefit on the “529 plans for Maya + Ethan (Boston)” example


College savings planning has gotten more interesting since Secure 2.0. Money you over-save in a 529 can roll into the beneficiary's Roth IRA — up to $35,000 per beneficiary, subject to annual contribution limits and a 15-year-old account requirement. Our calculator factors that exit door into the savings target so you don't end up with a stranded balance.
Plan for one kid or six. Each gets their own start age, target school tier (in-state public, out-of-state public, private), and inflation assumption. The calculator solves for the monthly contribution to hit your funding goal and shows the projected balance and Roth-rollover headroom in retirement.
Excess balances can be rolled to the beneficiary's Roth IRA under Secure 2.0 — up to $35,000 lifetime per beneficiary, subject to annual Roth contribution limits and a 15-year-old account. The calculator surfaces the rollover capacity so you can right-size the savings rate.
Yes. Pick your state and filing status and the calculator estimates your annual and lifetime state income-tax savings from 529 contributions, using each state's deduction cap and top marginal rate, or its credit where the state gives one. State rules change — confirm specifics with your plan or a CPA.
Yes — add as many beneficiaries as you want. Each is independent.
Start with tuition and fees, then add room and board, books, supplies, required equipment, travel, and a cushion for annual price increases. If the student may live at home or attend community college first, model that as a lower-cost scenario instead of averaging everything together.
Scholarships, grants, and family aid can reduce what the 529 needs to cover. Model a lower funding target or create a scholarship scenario so you can see whether the monthly contribution still makes sense.
Practical examples that connect the calculator to real planning decisions.
Compare a 529 plan vs a taxable brokerage for college savings with a concrete 12-year scenario, tax drag, flexibility tradeoffs, and 529 overfunding risks.
Saving too much in a 529 is usually manageable, but it is still worth planning. See the options for unused 529 money and a concrete surplus scenario.
Use a concrete 529 example to estimate monthly college savings, then test the number against inflation, current savings, and target school type.
Other calculators, planners and tools that pair well with the 529 College Savings Calculator.
Photo by Vitolda Klein on Unsplash.