Skip to main content
planin30

Investment Property Calculator — Buy a rental, or invest the same cash?

Put the house you’re looking at beside the stock market, with the same money going in. See the cash it costs or earns each month, and what each leaves you after the years you’d hold it.

  • Free to start
  • No sign-up to try
  • Compares it with the stock market
A woman weighing up a Phoenix rental house while an agent points out the roof
Priya, Phoenix rental, 15 yearsStocks end $39,000 ahead

Everything in one comparison

A rental is a loan, a tenant and a house that may grow in value. The same cash in stocks just grows. This counts both, month by month, so you can see which leaves you ahead.

Rental or stocks

The same cash, two ways to put it to work.

The down payment and closing costs go into the house, or into stocks. The rental’s monthly cash flow is invested when it’s positive and counted against it when it isn’t. At the end, the house is sold and both are compared.

“In this scenario, the stocks side ends with $39,000 more than the rental property”The answer on the “Long-term rental in Phoenix (Priya)” example
  • The same starting cash on both sides
  • Sale proceeds after selling costs
  • Net worth on each, every year
The rental beside the same cash in stocks, then net worth on each over fifteen years: Who ends ahead

Who ends ahead 2/2

A man comparing a rental listing with his investments at a laptop

Cash flow

What it costs or earns, every month.

Rent comes in after vacancy and the manager’s fee; the mortgage, taxes, insurance and upkeep go out. See the year’s cash flow, the tax benefit and the appreciation, and the numbers a lender or a partner will ask for.

Rent $2,300 a month · all costs $2,571 · −$308 a month out of pocket in year 1Key numbers on the Phoenix example
  • Income and expenses, year by year
  • Net monthly cash flow after vacancy and management
  • Break-even rent, appreciation and return
Annual cash flow on the rental and the stocks, then the key numbers: Cash flow, year by year

Cash flow, year by year 1/2

A couple looking over the empty kitchen of a rental house, talking it through

What it costs to own

Start from where the house is.

Pick the state and the property tax, insurance and closing costs start from its figures, with the national range beside them. Then type the real ones from the listing and your insurance quote.

Mortgage $1,783 · property tax $312 · insurance $113 · other $363 a monthYear 1 monthly cost on the Phoenix example
  • Property tax and insurance from the state
  • Closing costs, PMI and selling costs
  • Other costs, itemized or as one figure
Operating expenses: property tax of $312 a month and insurance of $113, with the typical range for each
A couple fixing the porch light of their rental house

Already own one

Keep it, sell it, or trade it for another.

Switch to “I already own one” and put in what it would sell for, the loan, your basis and the depreciation you’ve taken. See the cash a sale leaves after every tax, then four choices side by side over the years: sell today, sell later, keep it for life, or trade it for another rental with a 1031 exchange.

Sell today: $434,761 after $178,439 of tax · keep for life: $1.68M in 25 years, in today’s dollarsRuth’s Sacramento duplex, owned for over 20 years
  • Depreciation recapture, capital gains and state tax on a sale
  • Keeping for life: your heirs’ basis steps up and the tax goes away
  • A 1031 exchange: the tax put off, and what the new rental would earn
The cash a sale today leaves, the choices side by side, then wealth over the years four ways: Keep or sell

Keep or sell 1/2

An older couple going over papers at a patio table, deciding what to do with a rental

Start with the house you’re looking at.

Free to start. No sign-up to try.

Run the numbers on a rental →

About the Investment Property Calculator

A rental property pencils out on cap rate, but the wealth question is whether you'd be better off with the same capital in a low-cost index fund. Our calculator runs both side-by-side over your hold period, accounting for depreciation recapture, capital gains, and the leverage advantage of real estate.

Inputs: purchase price, down payment, rate, expected rent, vacancy, expenses, appreciation. Outputs: cap rate, cash-on-cash, IRR, after-tax wealth at sale, and the same cohort's wealth if invested in a 70/30 portfolio instead.

What you can do

  • Cap rate and cash-on-cash return
  • IRR over hold period with leverage
  • Depreciation and recapture modeling
  • Side-by-side comparison vs equity portfolio
  • National-average vacancy & expense defaults (override per deal)
  • Already own one? Keep, sell or trade it (1031), with the tax on a sale

Frequently asked questions

How do cap rate, cash-on-cash return, and IRR differ?

Cap rate is the property's yearly net operating income divided by price, before debt. Cash-on-cash return compares annual cash flow after the mortgage with the cash you invested. IRR folds in cash flow, appreciation, debt paydown, taxes, and sale proceeds over the full hold period.

What expenses should I include before deciding if a rental cash-flows?

Include vacancy, maintenance, repairs, property management, insurance, property taxes, HOA dues, utilities you cover, leasing costs, and a reserve for bigger replacements. A deal that works only when those are zero is probably too tight.

How do depreciation and recapture affect the return?

Depreciation can reduce taxable rental income while you own the property, but some of that benefit may be taxed back when you sell through depreciation recapture. The calculator estimates the tax effect, but a CPA should check the exact treatment.

Can rental losses offset my W-2 income?

Sometimes, but rental real estate is often treated as passive activity. Income, participation, and at-risk rules can limit the deduction, so model tax benefits conservatively and verify with a tax pro.

What makes a rental property too risky even if the return looks good?

Thin cash reserves, optimistic rent growth, no vacancy allowance, ignored repairs, a variable-rate loan, or one large expense wiping out a year of cash flow are warning signs. A good return should still work after stress-testing rent, vacancy, maintenance, and the sale price.

I already own a rental. Should I keep it, sell it, or do a 1031 exchange?

Switch the calculator to “I already own one”. It works out the cash a sale today leaves after depreciation recapture, capital gains, the 3.8% investment income tax and state tax, then compares selling today, selling later, keeping it for life (your heirs’ basis steps up, so that tax never comes due) and trading it for another rental through a 1031 exchange, which puts the tax off rather than forgiving it.

Related articles

Practical examples that connect the calculator to real planning decisions.

Related calculators and tools

Other calculators and tools that pair well with the Investment Property Calculator.